Skip to main content

Study: Which fast food restaurant gives you the worst bang for your buck?

Fast-casual restaurants: Where customers say they get the most value for their money

Whether we care to admit it or not, we all have our favorite fast-food restaurants. For all the bad rap they get, there’s really just no comparing their convenience or ability to satisfy that insane, so-bad-it’s-good, otherworldy craving for a greasy brown bagged burger and fries. Say what you will about the extra fat and calories, overly processed ingredients, and insane levels of sodium and cholesterol. At the end of the day, sometimes you’ve just got to give in and be bad.

And while we all have our favorites, from McDonald’s to Jimmy John’s, in a recent study, some fast-casual restaurants fared better than others when it came down to the best bang for your buck.

The most expensive fast-casual/fast-food restaurants in the U.S.

The study, conducted by Stifel, looked at some of the major fast-food and fast-casual restaurants and their average prices per meal across 20 cities.

  1. Panera Bread: $14.76
  2. Chipotle: $14.34
  3. Blaze Pizza: $13.72
  4. Shake Shack: $13.50
  5. Jersey Mike’s: $13.23
  6. MOD Pizza: $12.68
  7. Jimmy John’s: $11.06
  8. Panda Express: $10.32
  9. Wendy’s: $9.89
  10. Taco Bell: $9.69

This isn’t a list of every chain out there — Five Guys, for instance, was not included in the study. However, it does provide a snapshot of pricing. Unsurprisingly, Panera Bread and Chipotle topped the list of the most expensive restaurants. A given, considering very few would expect to pay the same amount for a fresh steak burrito as they would drive-thru chicken nuggets. But the lack of surprise ends there.

1,280 people were surveyed and asked, “Which restaurant(s) do you believe have become too expensive for what you get?” Unexpectedly, the overwhelming response was Shake Shack. While it’s only the fourth most expensive restaurant on the list of those studied, those polled strongly agreed that the amount and quality of food were considerably lacking for its cost.

MarketWatch reports that a Shake Shack representative, upon hearing this report, simply referred to the following statement from a recent company earnings report: “In menu innovation, we continue to lead the way with dynamic and fun products, providing our guests with elevated, premium, high-quality ingredients that they can’t find in traditional fast food, other fast-casual concepts or even casual dining. A Shack burger, fries, and beverage is on average under $14, well within and often priced below the cost of other lunch or dinner options nearby.”

Sorry, Shake Shack. Dynamic and fun are all well and good, but it seems the people want something you’re not providing.

Classic, tried-and-true staples of American cuisine, McDonald’s and Taco Bell, however, continue to impress customers despite inflation costs. The study found that despite being two of the three lowest-priced options, their satisfaction rates were unmatched by any other restaurant.

Here’s how the rest of the restaurants in the study fared (the list goes from least value for money, according to survey participants, to most):

  1. Shake Shack
  2. Blaze Pizza
  3. Mod Pizza
  4. Panera Bread
  5. Chick-fil-A
  6. Panda Express
  7. Chipotle
  8. Jersey Mike’s
  9. Jimmy John’s
  10. Wendy’s
  11. Taco Bell
  12. McDonald’s

Where does your favorite guilty pleasure restaurant fall on the list?

Editors' Recommendations

Lindsay Parrill
Lindsay is a graduate of California Culinary Academy, Le Cordon Bleu, San Francisco, from where she holds a degree in…
Yes, you should be preheating an air fryer — here’s why
Learn how to get the most out of your air fryer
Putting fried chicken into the tray of an air fryer

It's the latest food fad that doesn't seem to be going anywhere, the healthy cook's dream, the now hallowed and exalted air fryer. The hype around this countertop wonder doesn't seem to be dying down, either, with new recipes and rave reviews popping up everywhere in recent years. Boasting the ability to prepare healthier versions of countless foods, from "fried" chicken to potato chips, by using little to no oil, it's no wonder the air fryer has such adoring fans.

How does an air fryer work?
The science behind the air fryer's magic is really quite simple. It works similarly to a convection oven by circulating air around the food at very high temperatures, causing the food to crisp and brown without the need for added fats. Deep-fried flavor without the deep-fried calories? Not a bad deal. But as this handy gadget is still a relative newbie to the kitchen counter, there are still things to learn about this little appliance and how to best operate it.
Something to keep in mind is that air fryers produce very high temperatures very quickly. Unlike an oven that takes a good bit of time to preheat, an air fryer will preheat in just a short amount of time. While this is very handy in a lot of cases, the quick heating time also makes it easier to burn food, so use those timers carefully!

Read more
9 best food sources for getting beta-carotene in your diet
These amazing beta-carotene foods will help improve your health
Sweet potato wedges.

Have you noticed how some plants, vegetables, and fruits have bright colors? The reason for this vibrant trait is compounds called carotenoids. Carotenoids are natural pigments produced by certain plants for the purpose of lighter energy absorption and conversion. One common example of a carotenoid is beta-carotene.

Do beta-carotene foods have any benefits? Can you consume it directly? Or does it even have any food sources you can include in your diet? Before answering these questions, it would be best to know what beta-carotene is. So, it’s time to dive in!

Read more
The great lobster roll battle pits Maine vs. Connecticut: Which is better?
New England makes a mean lobster roll. Which style is better, Maine or Connecticut?

Anyone who’s spent time in coastal New England is undoubtedly aware of the region’s deep-seated love for cooking lobster. While most lobster fishing occurs in the far-northern state of Maine, chefs throughout the Northeast make use of this delicious crustacean, creating everything from lobster mac and cheese to classic Lobster Thermidor to the handheld wonder known as the lobster roll.

Primarily filled with the tender and flavorful meat of the lobster knuckle (with some claw and tail meat to round it out), a lobster roll typically comes in one of two styles: the Maine lobster roll and the Connecticut lobster roll. These New England inventions feature drastically different preparations, temperatures, and tastes. As a result, they each have passionate fans and equally passionate detractors. But in the Maine vs. Connecticut lobster roll battle, is there a clear winner?

Read more